Fees etc.
Moderators: sky's the limit, sepia, Sulako, lilfssister, North Shore, I WAS Birddog
- Cat Driver
- Top Poster
- Posts: 18921
- Joined: Sun Feb 15, 2004 8:31 pm
Fees etc.
The discussions ongoing about the medical processing fee is really interesting, especially those who feel these fees are justified.
So how about you willing fees payers list the services TC provides that you are really satisfied with and would be willingly paid outside of government?
So how about you willing fees payers list the services TC provides that you are really satisfied with and would be willingly paid outside of government?
The hardest thing about flying is knowing when to say no
After over a half a century of flying no one ever died because of my decision not to fly.
After over a half a century of flying no one ever died because of my decision not to fly.
Re: Fees etc.
I hate paying fees.
However, I like the idea of an enforcement agency that lays smack downs against morons who deliberately and negligently put themselves and the public at risk. They don't do enough policing. Wish it was more like the Mossad. Imagine the scandal, Johnny Ramp-rat pulling rank shutting down an op? Would actually make for a good tv series.
However, I like the idea of an enforcement agency that lays smack downs against morons who deliberately and negligently put themselves and the public at risk. They don't do enough policing. Wish it was more like the Mossad. Imagine the scandal, Johnny Ramp-rat pulling rank shutting down an op? Would actually make for a good tv series.
- YYZSaabGuy
- Rank 8
- Posts: 851
- Joined: Wed Aug 04, 2010 7:32 am
- Location: On glideslope.
Re: Fees etc.
Here's a better idea: how about you folks who kvetch endlessly about the medical processing fee come up with a viable alternative to the current "User Pay" scheme?Cat Driver wrote:The discussions ongoing about the medical processing fee is really interesting, especially those who feel these fees are justified.
So how about you willing fees payers list the services TC provides that you are really satisfied with and would be willingly paid outside of government?
Without, of course, increasing my already too-high federal, provincial and municipal taxes?
Or sacrificing the current levels of service, regardless of whether they could be improved?
Re: Fees etc.
They can't because there is no viable alternative. Unless they can find some way to administer licenses and do all the other work TC is mandated to do at no cost.YYZSaabGuy wrote:Here's a better idea: how about you folks who kvetch endlessly about the medical processing fee come up with a viable alternative to the current "User Pay" scheme?
Re: Fees etc.
Cat, sometimes I can't decide if you are purposely obtuse just to stimulate conversation or you actually have a reading comprehension problem.
Assuming I'm one of the folks you imply feels the fee is justified, I'll try once again to clarify my actual feelings.
It's not about whether the fees are justified or not, it's about whether they should be paid or not. You and I or anyone else on this forum ranting about the unfairness of it doesn't change anything. The reality is that the fees are part of the system and we are all aware that they are. So, by choosing to become a pilot and join the system, I (and by extension) all of us agree to operate within the system. I follow the regulations even though there are many of them I don't particularly agree with. I pay the fees that are part of the system even though there are many of them I don't particularly agree with.
The simple fact I do not agree with something doesn't give me the right to refuse to comply. If I feel very strongly that something is unfair or improper enough, I will take steps to try and change the system using appropriate methods. Or, I can choose not to be part of whatever activity/system it is I have an issue with. That is central to being a part of society.
Withholding a fee simply because I think it is unfair is just like busting a regulation simply because I think it is unfair.
Assuming I'm one of the folks you imply feels the fee is justified, I'll try once again to clarify my actual feelings.
It's not about whether the fees are justified or not, it's about whether they should be paid or not. You and I or anyone else on this forum ranting about the unfairness of it doesn't change anything. The reality is that the fees are part of the system and we are all aware that they are. So, by choosing to become a pilot and join the system, I (and by extension) all of us agree to operate within the system. I follow the regulations even though there are many of them I don't particularly agree with. I pay the fees that are part of the system even though there are many of them I don't particularly agree with.
The simple fact I do not agree with something doesn't give me the right to refuse to comply. If I feel very strongly that something is unfair or improper enough, I will take steps to try and change the system using appropriate methods. Or, I can choose not to be part of whatever activity/system it is I have an issue with. That is central to being a part of society.
Withholding a fee simply because I think it is unfair is just like busting a regulation simply because I think it is unfair.
Being stupid around airplanes is a capital offence and nature is a hanging judge!
“It ain't what you don't know that gets you into trouble. It's what you know for sure that just ain't so.”
Mark Twain
“It ain't what you don't know that gets you into trouble. It's what you know for sure that just ain't so.”
Mark Twain
- Cat Driver
- Top Poster
- Posts: 18921
- Joined: Sun Feb 15, 2004 8:31 pm
Re: Fees etc.
Sounds reasonable, maybe you could let us know how you would go about doing that with the present system in power?I will take steps to try and change the system using appropriate methods.
Or, I can choose not to be part of whatever activity/system it is I have an issue with.
Exactly, comply or be unable to work in the profession you chose to work in.
Yes, however this is not the society I started to work in, back then DOT actually gave you a tangible service and you could actually communicate one on one with them....all paid out of my taxes...no add on fees.That is central to being a part of society.
Fortunately I worked outside of this system for decades before I retired mostly flying under FAA part 91, which is eons ahead of the Canadian way of operating.
What you have now is bureaucracy at its best...
Canada has some positive aspects though, if you want to go on welfare no problem the less you can do the easier it is to get approved.
Gotta love socialism.
The hardest thing about flying is knowing when to say no
After over a half a century of flying no one ever died because of my decision not to fly.
After over a half a century of flying no one ever died because of my decision not to fly.
- Shiny Side Up
- Top Poster
- Posts: 5335
- Joined: Tue Feb 17, 2004 5:02 pm
- Location: Group W bench
Re: Fees etc.
To be honest, the level of service has steadily declined. I sort of doubt that this is because some aren't paying their fees. Since one has been paying fees before with better service, one might consider that witholding fees is a means of protest. Part of the problem is also that we're not getting what we agreed to pay fees for, and given the level of service, we don't even get reasonable notice when its reduced.YYZSaabGuy wrote:Or sacrificing the current levels of service, regardless of whether they could be improved?
One sore point on the whole process. Notably its been taking TC up to their "standard of service" of 90 days to process paper on a regular basis. Bizarrely, you almost immediately get a notice of your fee for your medical sometime weeks - or months, before you even get the paper in hand. On the other side of things TC seems short staffed, why is the fees department the only bit that seems to be staffed up?
On a wider note, aviation fees are always a sore spot since it seem to be the only place where service and payment for service is disconnected. I'm not sure why this is. Why isn't TC licensing operating more like the provincial DMV? When it comes to airport fees I've never run into a more incompetent bunch that seem to get into this position at airports big and small, incompetent or crooked or both, that I'm not sure.
For some reason it never occurs to anyone in any of these positions that you have an easier time collecting fees if you have a good level of service. Rather they approach it in the same vein as "the beatings will continue until morale improves".
I love socialism. What we got sometimes though ain't socialism. If we were more socialist, we'd get more service for the tax burden. As it is, its more of a kleptocracy.Gotta love socialism.
We can't stop here! This is BAT country!
- Cat Driver
- Top Poster
- Posts: 18921
- Joined: Sun Feb 15, 2004 8:31 pm
Re: Fees etc.
F I N A L L Y ! ! !
Someone understands the issue.
Now we all can feel more Canadian.
Someone understands the issue.
Here let me take two words out out of this.As it is, its more of a kleptocracy.
There we go....As it is, its a kleptocracy.
Now we all can feel more Canadian.
The hardest thing about flying is knowing when to say no
After over a half a century of flying no one ever died because of my decision not to fly.
After over a half a century of flying no one ever died because of my decision not to fly.
Re: Fees etc.
The highlighted / bold points are the problem, not the fee.Cat Driver wrote:Sounds reasonable, maybe you could let us know how you would go about doing that with the present system in power?I will take steps to try and change the system using appropriate methods.Or, I can choose not to be part of whatever activity/system it is I have an issue with.
Exactly, comply or be unable to work in the profession you chose to work in.
Yes, however this is not the society I started to work in, back then DOT actually gave you a tangible service and you could actually communicate one on one with them....all paid out of my taxes...no add on fees.That is central to being a part of society.
Fortunately I worked outside of this system for decades before I retired mostly flying under FAA part 91, which is eons ahead of the Canadian way of operating.
What you have now is bureaucracy at its best...
Canada has some positive aspects though, if you want to go on welfare no problem the less you can do the easier it is to get approved.
Gotta love socialism.
Yes, and the U.S. has so much going for it these days I can't help but wonder why I retain my Canadian citizenship
You remind me of those hypocritical radical western imams who condemn all aspects of the country they call home but choose to remain well inside it's borders.
Give up, enjoy your weekend.
- Cat Driver
- Top Poster
- Posts: 18921
- Joined: Sun Feb 15, 2004 8:31 pm
Re: Fees etc.
I am enjoying my weekend.Give up, enjoy your weekend.
In three more days I will wander into a new location, in Tucson now , may head over to Hemet for a while.
I am able to afford this life style because I chose to work outside of Canada once I was unable to work here, courtesy of Transport Canada.
The hardest thing about flying is knowing when to say no
After over a half a century of flying no one ever died because of my decision not to fly.
After over a half a century of flying no one ever died because of my decision not to fly.
Re: Fees etc.
There are three sides to every storyCat Driver wrote:I am enjoying my weekend.Give up, enjoy your weekend.
In three more days I will wander into a new location, in Tucson now , may head over to Hemet for a while.
I am able to afford this life style because I chose to work outside of Canada once I was unable to work here, courtesy of Transport Canada.
- Cat Driver
- Top Poster
- Posts: 18921
- Joined: Sun Feb 15, 2004 8:31 pm
Re: Fees etc.
Yes there are.
There are three sides to every story
The third side of my story is I won my legal battle with TC and they were found to have been in violation of the very laws they are sworn to uphold.
Did I detect a slight inference you thought I had been to blame for the situation I was in?
The hardest thing about flying is knowing when to say no
After over a half a century of flying no one ever died because of my decision not to fly.
After over a half a century of flying no one ever died because of my decision not to fly.
Re: Fees etc.
I don't know what situation you were in. On that note, I do not hate all police officers just because I've had a bad experience with a few authoritarian dirty corrupt scum bags who make things up, like your speed. You know, the cases which are tossed out of court because they're so asinine .
Your favorite flying gig was what? Warm change in topic.
Your favorite flying gig was what? Warm change in topic.
- Cat Driver
- Top Poster
- Posts: 18921
- Joined: Sun Feb 15, 2004 8:31 pm
Re: Fees etc.
Yet you chose to describe me this way.I don't know what situation you were in.
I was forced to work outside of Canada by several very corrupt TC high level managers, it cost me a company and three and a half years of legal battles to finally win my case.You remind me of those hypocritical radical western imams who condemn all aspects of the country they call home but choose to remain well inside it's borders.
It went up the ladder of power to the Director General Transport Canada, the Minister of Transport and finally to the head of the Justice Department in Ottawa.
The findings were completely in my favor and TC was found guilty of denying me due process.....which every Canadian citizen is guaranteed.
Maybe you should think before you make derogatory comments about people you know nothing about.
Aerial application, especially flying helicopters in that role.Your favorite flying gig was what? Warm change in topic.
The worst gig was eight years of airshow flying in Europe.
The hardest thing about flying is knowing when to say no
After over a half a century of flying no one ever died because of my decision not to fly.
After over a half a century of flying no one ever died because of my decision not to fly.
Re: Fees etc.
From the way you write, it sounds like you have a case of sour grapes because of one experience. My police officer analogy is perfect.
I've read these forums for years.
I've read these forums for years.
- Cat Driver
- Top Poster
- Posts: 18921
- Joined: Sun Feb 15, 2004 8:31 pm
Re: Fees etc.
You are entitled to have any opinion you wish.
As too sour grapes that also is an opinion you are entitled to, however from my own experience in aviation I can look back and feel nothing but success from day one in a career that allowed me to fly in so many different types of flying in so many different aircraft I can hardly believe I did it....
...and to make it even better I made enough to be comfortable for a very long time..
So if that is sour grapes the taste is delicious.
We really have nothing more to discuss ...
Hope your career will be as good as mine was.
As too sour grapes that also is an opinion you are entitled to, however from my own experience in aviation I can look back and feel nothing but success from day one in a career that allowed me to fly in so many different types of flying in so many different aircraft I can hardly believe I did it....
...and to make it even better I made enough to be comfortable for a very long time..
So if that is sour grapes the taste is delicious.
We really have nothing more to discuss ...
Hope your career will be as good as mine was.
The hardest thing about flying is knowing when to say no
After over a half a century of flying no one ever died because of my decision not to fly.
After over a half a century of flying no one ever died because of my decision not to fly.
Re: Fees etc.
On topic, my police officer analogy again is perfect.
By the sounds of it you want no enforcement in Canada. What a wonderful world that would be.
By the sounds of it you want no enforcement in Canada. What a wonderful world that would be.
Re: Fees etc.
I'm like the fee nazi. I hate them, and everyone has them. Buy a new phone for $500 and get charged a $25 fee to activate it, why do I have to pay the guy to do his job after shelling out serious cash for a product at the store he works for? Buy new tires for your car and pay a fee for the old ones to be recycled, I don't have to pay a restaurant to throw out the food I didn't eat. Buy a $1800 plane ticket and pay the airport a $25 improvement fee, why doesn't the airport charge it's tenants more - I don't pay improvement fees at the mall. Want electricity in Ontario, well there is a delivery fee for that too. Call out charge for fuel, am I not a customer? Pay $150 to have a doctor give me a 5 minute once over, then pay TC $50 to put the paper in my file. Enough.
We pay taxes out the ass, federal tax, provincial tax, municipal tax, tax on every cent we spend in Canada (gst/pst/hst whatever) and tax on every cent we earn in Canada. We even pay tax on something that already has had the taxes paid, like a used car. Guy buys a car from the dealership and pays $X in tax to the government, I buy that car off him 2 years later and I'm paying tax again on that car! If you haven't realized that you're getting totally bent over by everyone yet, you will. One day, like me, your brain will click and you will say "what the eff". Enough is enough. My moment was with the cell company Fido. I bought a phone without a contract, paid top nut too. $25 to "activate" it. He is doing his job, activating my phone is his job, his employer is making money off my monthly phone bill as well as the product I just purchased, now they want me to pay their employees to do their job? What the... Why are we putting up with this? Because it's become normal. It's become normal and it shouldn't be. I didn't buy that phone, that fee cost fido a customer as I switched companies after 14 years of service. I don't stand for fees, cable company tried to charge me to come and replace their broken equipment, I told them their broken garbage will be on my step and that I'll switch companies... Fee was waved. Canadians are paying more money now in taxes, fees, additional charges, and surcharges to the government alone then ever before, but you are getting LESS back. Everyone has their hand in your pocket, how much is left for you? In most cases it's either not enough or just enough. More Canadians then ever are living pay cheque to pay cheque, taxes, fees, surcharges, delivery fees, they add up quick. I used to pay my bank fees to keep my money, they make money off my money then charge me more. That stopped because I told them no more. Cable company, phone company, I don't pay them fees. TC, no I won't pay those, and if they go to collection I'll take satisfaction knowing they paid the collection agency a fee. Grow a back bone and say enough already, get you greasy hands out of my wallet.
End of rant.
We pay taxes out the ass, federal tax, provincial tax, municipal tax, tax on every cent we spend in Canada (gst/pst/hst whatever) and tax on every cent we earn in Canada. We even pay tax on something that already has had the taxes paid, like a used car. Guy buys a car from the dealership and pays $X in tax to the government, I buy that car off him 2 years later and I'm paying tax again on that car! If you haven't realized that you're getting totally bent over by everyone yet, you will. One day, like me, your brain will click and you will say "what the eff". Enough is enough. My moment was with the cell company Fido. I bought a phone without a contract, paid top nut too. $25 to "activate" it. He is doing his job, activating my phone is his job, his employer is making money off my monthly phone bill as well as the product I just purchased, now they want me to pay their employees to do their job? What the... Why are we putting up with this? Because it's become normal. It's become normal and it shouldn't be. I didn't buy that phone, that fee cost fido a customer as I switched companies after 14 years of service. I don't stand for fees, cable company tried to charge me to come and replace their broken equipment, I told them their broken garbage will be on my step and that I'll switch companies... Fee was waved. Canadians are paying more money now in taxes, fees, additional charges, and surcharges to the government alone then ever before, but you are getting LESS back. Everyone has their hand in your pocket, how much is left for you? In most cases it's either not enough or just enough. More Canadians then ever are living pay cheque to pay cheque, taxes, fees, surcharges, delivery fees, they add up quick. I used to pay my bank fees to keep my money, they make money off my money then charge me more. That stopped because I told them no more. Cable company, phone company, I don't pay them fees. TC, no I won't pay those, and if they go to collection I'll take satisfaction knowing they paid the collection agency a fee. Grow a back bone and say enough already, get you greasy hands out of my wallet.
End of rant.
Re: Fees etc.
^ ^ ^ Well said ^ ^ ^ I like the way you think.
There is no substitute for BIG JUGS!!
- glorifieddriver
- Rank 3
- Posts: 134
- Joined: Sun Jul 11, 2010 12:30 am
- Location: CYYZ
Re: Fees etc.
justwork wrote:I'm like the fee nazi. I hate them, and everyone has them. Buy a new phone for $500 and get charged a $25 fee to activate it, why do I have to pay the guy to do his job after shelling out serious cash for a product at the store he works for? Buy new tires for your car and pay a fee for the old ones to be recycled, I don't have to pay a restaurant to throw out the food I didn't eat. Buy a $1800 plane ticket and pay the airport a $25 improvement fee, why doesn't the airport charge it's tenants more - I don't pay improvement fees at the mall. Want electricity in Ontario, well there is a delivery fee for that too. Call out charge for fuel, am I not a customer? Pay $150 to have a doctor give me a 5 minute once over, then pay TC $50 to put the paper in my file. Enough.
We pay taxes out the ass, federal tax, provincial tax, municipal tax, tax on every cent we spend in Canada (gst/pst/hst whatever) and tax on every cent we earn in Canada. We even pay tax on something that already has had the taxes paid, like a used car. Guy buys a car from the dealership and pays $X in tax to the government, I buy that car off him 2 years later and I'm paying tax again on that car! If you haven't realized that you're getting totally bent over by everyone yet, you will. One day, like me, your brain will click and you will say "what the eff". Enough is enough. My moment was with the cell company Fido. I bought a phone without a contract, paid top nut too. $25 to "activate" it. He is doing his job, activating my phone is his job, his employer is making money off my monthly phone bill as well as the product I just purchased, now they want me to pay their employees to do their job? What the... Why are we putting up with this? Because it's become normal. It's become normal and it shouldn't be. I didn't buy that phone, that fee cost fido a customer as I switched companies after 14 years of service. I don't stand for fees, cable company tried to charge me to come and replace their broken equipment, I told them their broken garbage will be on my step and that I'll switch companies... Fee was waved. Canadians are paying more money now in taxes, fees, additional charges, and surcharges to the government alone then ever before, but you are getting LESS back. Everyone has their hand in your pocket, how much is left for you? In most cases it's either not enough or just enough. More Canadians then ever are living pay cheque to pay cheque, taxes, fees, surcharges, delivery fees, they add up quick. I used to pay my bank fees to keep my money, they make money off my money then charge me more. That stopped because I told them no more. Cable company, phone company, I don't pay them fees. TC, no I won't pay those, and if they go to collection I'll take satisfaction knowing they paid the collection agency a fee. Grow a back bone and say enough already, get you greasy hands out of my wallet.
End of rant.
Time to revolt! On a more serious note though, if you consider the fact that when you roll over $50,000.00 income and with every $10,000.00 on top of that your ability to improve life really does not improve! Making let's say $80,000.00 you should be able to afford a nice phone, car, a vacation every now and then....but in reality the taxation and fee structure imposed on us, really quickly brings your $80,000.00 to a fraction of that amount. If you really add up all the money you work for that is just being taken away from you, you will loose any kind of motivation. All of us professionals in the $50,000ish to $150,000ish mark are being taken for a ride the most. We have no way to write off expenses (expensive car, hotels, restaurants, etc) that a simple business owner (even scammer) can do with the same income. He will clear over 80% and we will under 50%!!! What sense is there to go to school, study, become a person of a trait...when you just simply get treated for a retard and stolen of your pay cheque! Just open a business, any business that you can really make a go of that can get you $100k in the door. You will clear more money than most of us at well beyond a $150K mark!
So yeah, the extra $50 a year, as little as they may sound add up, to the other $50 $25 $100 fees and then taxes and there you have it, what are you really working for?