Thing is, you have to have a fair bit of flying or life experience to effectively teach risk management. (painting with broad strokes here) Most young flight instructors have neither...rookiepilot wrote: ↑Wed Nov 29, 2017 4:21 pm
And while we're on the subject, is there some reason simple risk management principles for PPL's can't be taught during the syllabus? Yes the herd will tell me it is taught. I say most do a piss poor job on this principle, somewhere between the teaching and the learning.
Weather knowledge too.
Missing airplane on flight from Penticton to Edmonton
Moderators: sky's the limit, sepia, Sulako, lilfssister, North Shore
-
- Rank 5
- Posts: 383
- Joined: Sat Aug 30, 2014 7:19 pm
Re: Missing airplane on flight from Penticton to Edmonton
Everything has an end, except a sausage, which has two!
Re: Missing airplane on flight from Penticton to Edmonton
EDIT (Dec 3rd):rookiepilot wrote: ↑Thu Nov 30, 2017 7:07 pmSo the pilots decision to take off had nothing to do with it?
Used the wrong day ... my mistake ( wow .. how did I not see that )
Nov 25 .. not 27th
Last edited by pdw on Sun Dec 03, 2017 6:24 am, edited 1 time in total.
-
- Rank 8
- Posts: 899
- Joined: Fri Mar 05, 2010 10:16 pm
- Location: A sigma left of the top of the bell curve
Re: Missing airplane on flight from Penticton to Edmonton
From the Castanet article: "'We have not searched east of Rogers Pass as there was no ping information with the Rogers Pass cellphone tower from the phone on board the plane. It did communicate with the Fidelity Mountain cell tower near the west boundary of Glacier Park,' she read from an update provided to the family." For anyone not familiar with the pass, it makes an S-turn, with the head of the pass at the middle of the S, and then turns north, so the route goes east, north a bit, east a bit, and then north again. If the vis was poor and the pilot was unfamiliar with the route, he could easily have missed one of those turns and continued up the wrong valley, in particular I'm thinking that first turn north towards the head of the pass. I've made the same mistake in snow before in a different location when it was hard to tell which road to follow, but I was lucky enough to turn back while I still could.
- rookiepilot
- Rank 11
- Posts: 4413
- Joined: Sat Apr 01, 2017 3:50 pm
Re: Missing airplane on flight from Penticton to Edmonton
One of the primary things to learn and anyone will tell you, in a light, low performance aircraft, 40 -50 knot upper winds are really bad in the mountains.pdw wrote: ↑Fri Dec 01, 2017 2:26 pmI'm inclined to think you may be right on with that line of questioning on this. Figures out ... hey why not take advantage of a higher groundspeed (figures out 2 and 2 ... will get through there faster and way before dark). A 35-40-kts sustained in the mooney on the NE course to Edmonton .. if that component was predicted WSW/SW up there .... and if it's true no real experience in the mountains to fully grasp what exactly the risks are with the stronger numbers?rookiepilot wrote: ↑Thu Nov 30, 2017 7:07 pmSo the pilots decision to take off had nothing to do with it?
Re: Missing airplane on flight from Penticton to Edmonton
EDIT: My apologies to Cnpc .. RookiePilot .. and anyone else .. for the wrong date / wrong metar ... only 15kts
That would be right past where the Trans Canada loops back on itself before heading north into the pass ....
Last edited by pdw on Sun Dec 03, 2017 10:32 am, edited 13 times in total.
-
- Rank 3
- Posts: 180
- Joined: Mon Nov 02, 2015 8:22 am
Re: Missing airplane on flight from Penticton to Edmonton
English words - yes.
English sentence - no.
- rookiepilot
- Rank 11
- Posts: 4413
- Joined: Sat Apr 01, 2017 3:50 pm
Re: Missing airplane on flight from Penticton to Edmonton
It is extremely easy to choose the wrong valley. On my one trip crossing the rocks in perfect weather, I started down the wrong valley, very similar, and only a relatively minor heading difference, to correct valley, for a few miles before realizing the heading did not make sense with the map (I was practising without GPS assistance).
Must be double checking navigation , finger on the map.
Must be double checking navigation , finger on the map.
Re: Missing airplane on flight from Penticton to Edmonton
That makes sense then to retrace the map similar way to pinpoint 'most likely spot" for such nav error potential (as per previous page discussion .. ie "could easily have misssed one of those turns").RookiePilot wrote:and only a relatively minor heading difference, to correct valley
One or two track-points from which an error-deviation was more-likely and also passing within Fidelity Mt cellphonetower's service area wherein the ping of the PICs cellphone is being sourced (this being the cellphone service area centered 32km past Revelstoke and 29km past the last on-track radar hit about 2 miles NE of town) can be considered.
EDIT:
I used Nov27th data by mistake, ..on the 25th there was 15kts up there at Mt Des Poilus.
Last edited by pdw on Sun Dec 03, 2017 6:29 am, edited 1 time in total.
Re: Missing airplane on flight from Penticton to Edmonton
In that area, with winds comparable to what have been posted here, I've had a lightly loaded sr22 turbo firewalled and still descending at 1500 feet per minute. That experience would have been a lot less fun in a 200hp Mooney.
Does anyone have the ability to post the GFA from that day?
Does anyone have the ability to post the GFA from that day?
Re: Missing airplane on flight from Penticton to Edmonton
Stallspin wrote: ↑Sat Dec 02, 2017 4:43 pm In that area, with winds comparable to what have been posted here, I've had a lightly loaded sr22 turbo firewalled and still descending at 1500 feet per minute. That experience would have been a lot less fun in a 200hp Mooney.
Does anyone have the ability to post the GFA from that day?
Is that what you're looking for?
Re: Missing airplane on flight from Penticton to Edmonton
I think it's this one:Does anyone have the ability to post the GFA from that day?
http://gfaarchive.info/gfaDisplay.php?r ... Offset=000
I think PDW and CNPC might have been looking at the wrong day. The plane departed Sat afternoon, but you both were looking at the Sun afternoon weather. The weather actually looks fine from what I can see. The only minor concern is that green hatched area, but it would have been easy enough to see if that had been a problem. Only other concern would be that Lee trough which could indicate strong mountain winds, so I'd want to check the upper winds. I'd also want to check weather at Golden and Revelstoke in case that scattered cloud at 6000ft had gotten any worse than forecast.
-
- Rank 8
- Posts: 899
- Joined: Fri Mar 05, 2010 10:16 pm
- Location: A sigma left of the top of the bell curve
Re: Missing airplane on flight from Penticton to Edmonton
Scattered 6-8000 in those mountain passes can easily become a ceiling at a couple of thousand AGL locally in the valleys. Add in the conditions in the hatched area, and what you thought might be a nice VFR day can turn into a really bad trip. I've been through that area a lot, including on a day with nothing worse than SCT forecast when I almost got trapped; the clouds aren't enough to form a real ceiling over the whole area, but when you're in a narrow valley you can't really maneuver laterally to get by them like you could over flat terrain. If you don't leave enough room to turn around, you don't have any choice but to continue forward, and if the vis drops you're in real trouble. I personally won't go VFR through there with any forecast clouds lower than the tops of the mountains anymore, and that GFA looks pretty bad to me.CpnCrunch wrote: ↑Sat Dec 02, 2017 5:59 pmI think it's this one:Does anyone have the ability to post the GFA from that day?
http://gfaarchive.info/gfaDisplay.php?r ... Offset=000
I think PDW and CNPC might have been looking at the wrong day. The plane departed Sat afternoon, but you both were looking at the Sun afternoon weather. The weather actually looks fine from what I can see. The only minor concern is that green hatched area, but it would have been easy enough to see if that had been a problem. Only other concern would be that Lee trough which could indicate strong mountain winds, so I'd want to check the upper winds. I'd also want to check weather at Golden and Revelstoke in case that scattered cloud at 6000ft had gotten any worse than forecast.
- rookiepilot
- Rank 11
- Posts: 4413
- Joined: Sat Apr 01, 2017 3:50 pm
Re: Missing airplane on flight from Penticton to Edmonton
I agree with Diadem. Plus add with that GFA, someone tell me how exactly one is supposed to land in Edmonton? Unless I've misread the map and where I think Edmonton is, looks sketchy.
Trying to fly between those hatched areas....dicey even if clouds remained scattered otherwise.
Checkout the icing and turbulence graph, too.
http://gfaarchive.info/gfaDisplay.php?r ... Offset=000
No thanks for this cowboy. Too much risk.
Let's remind too a chunk of this flight was to be attempted in the Dark. Risk upon risk.
Trying to fly between those hatched areas....dicey even if clouds remained scattered otherwise.
Checkout the icing and turbulence graph, too.
http://gfaarchive.info/gfaDisplay.php?r ... Offset=000
No thanks for this cowboy. Too much risk.
Let's remind too a chunk of this flight was to be attempted in the Dark. Risk upon risk.
Last edited by rookiepilot on Sat Dec 02, 2017 9:11 pm, edited 1 time in total.
-
- Rank 7
- Posts: 683
- Joined: Sat Sep 17, 2005 9:27 am
- Location: Toronto
Re: Missing airplane on flight from Penticton to Edmonton
Mt des Poilus is on the other side of the Columbia Valley, pretty much North of Kicking Horse Pass. Any weather observation there can't really be extrapolated to Roger's Pass. Wind fields change a lot in the mountains.
I'd consider stopping by the Alpine Club Wheeler hut to see if anybody heard an aircraft The ACC national office knows who was booked there. There's also the avalanche control crew and CP. Wouldn't be surprised if SAR's already touched base with them. There are lots of people out and about in the West side of Roger's Pass. Somebody outside should have heard something if they went up that pass unless the wind was howling or a train was nearby.
There's other valleys north and south of Revelstoke where they could have gone up.
I'd consider stopping by the Alpine Club Wheeler hut to see if anybody heard an aircraft The ACC national office knows who was booked there. There's also the avalanche control crew and CP. Wouldn't be surprised if SAR's already touched base with them. There are lots of people out and about in the West side of Roger's Pass. Somebody outside should have heard something if they went up that pass unless the wind was howling or a train was nearby.
There's other valleys north and south of Revelstoke where they could have gone up.
Re: Missing airplane on flight from Penticton to Edmonton
Actual weather was scattered at 7000ft ay YRV and YGE. Not sure if there's any weather stations in the passes.
I don't think any of those valleys are particularly narrow, if you stick to the VFR route. I certainly agree that it's a bad idea to go up any narrow valleys in bad weather. Even in good weather it's not a good idea unless you know the area.when you're in a narrow valley you can't really maneuver laterally to get by them like you could over flat terrain.
Re: Missing airplane on flight from Penticton to Edmonton
I'm certainly not suggesting that anyone should go flying in marginal weather in the mountains, and as I said I'd have checked carefully to make sure the hatched area and lee trough weren't an issue before taking off.rookiepilot wrote: ↑Sat Dec 02, 2017 9:07 pm I agree with Diadem. Plus add with that GFA, someone tell me how exactly one is supposed to land in Edmonton? Unless I've misread the map and where I think Edmonton is, looks sketchy.
Trying to fly between those hatched areas....dicey even if clouds remained scattered otherwise.
Checkout the icing and turbulence graph, too.
http://gfaarchive.info/gfaDisplay.php?r ... Offset=000
No thanks for this cowboy. Too much risk.
Let's remind too a chunk of this flight was to be attempted in the Dark. Risk upon risk.
Icing isn't a factor here if you're below the clouds, which they would have been in the Mooney (unless utterly insane *EDIT I see they were below the clouds from the track log). Edmonton is in the clear area (go to the regular GFA on Navcanada's site and it will show airport name if you hover over the airport).
I'm not saying that people should necessarily fly in that weather. All I'm saying is that it isn't obvious from the GFA that the weather was really shitty at the time.
I agree that leaving at 2:30pm was a strange decision. It would mean they would barely be out of the mountains by sunset, with no margin for any delay.
Here is the track log:
http://flightaware.com/live/flight/CFES ... Z/tracklog
Looks like their last radar track was a slow circling descent over Revelstoke. Presumably they were ducking under the clouds at 7000ft, and were below radar coverage after that. (I assume they could have easily made the field if it was an engine failure or other emergency).
Last edited by CpnCrunch on Sun Dec 03, 2017 8:58 am, edited 1 time in total.
Re: Missing airplane on flight from Penticton to Edmonton
Nothing on the Flight Aware links.
Good judgment comes from experience. Experience often comes from bad judgment.
Re: Missing airplane on flight from Penticton to Edmonton
Link seems to work for me, but you can just search for CFESN on flightaware to get it.
Re: Missing airplane on flight from Penticton to Edmonton
You'll need an account with FlightAware to see it since it is a Position-Only Flight and you can only select that option with an account. It can be found under the My Account tab > 6 Position-Only Flights. VFR flights usually only show up if they have ADS-B Out or flight following has been used (i.e. transponder code assigned and entered in the ATC system).
When this option is activated, you can see additional flights for which FlightAware does not have a filed flight plan.
Tracking data for position-only flights is incomplete and potentially inaccurate.
Have Pratts - Will Travel
Re: Missing airplane on flight from Penticton to Edmonton
I have it now, thanks. Anybody got the 4 pm MST Metar for Revelstoke that day?Pratt X 3 wrote: ↑Sun Dec 03, 2017 11:25 amYou'll need an account with FlightAware to see it since it is a Position-Only Flight and you can only select that option with an account. It can be found under the My Account tab > 6 Position-Only Flights. VFR flights usually only show up if they have ADS-B Out or flight following has been used (i.e. transponder code assigned and entered in the ATC system).
When this option is activated, you can see additional flights for which FlightAware does not have a filed flight plan.
Tracking data for position-only flights is incomplete and potentially inaccurate.
It seems that Revelstoke was an enroute waypoint as the route is sort of direct there, and always to the northwest of the direct track between Penticton and Edmonton.
Good judgment comes from experience. Experience often comes from bad judgment.