How to get rid of ACPA?
Moderators: sky's the limit, sepia, Sulako, lilfssister, North Shore, I WAS Birddog
-
- Rank 3
- Posts: 153
- Joined: Wed Sep 02, 2020 10:24 am
Re: How to get rid of ACPA?
I wonder if the Negots Chair (Who is also the YWG LEC Chair) recused himself from the MEC vote to support or not support this MOA?
My guess is he was a BIG yes vote and did everything he could to convince everyone else to do the same.
Voting should be recorded. I want to know who voted for what and why.
My guess is he was a BIG yes vote and did everything he could to convince everyone else to do the same.
Voting should be recorded. I want to know who voted for what and why.
-
- Rank 5
- Posts: 339
- Joined: Fri Dec 05, 2008 7:59 am
Re: How to get rid of ACPA?
I don't work at AC, but I'll say this, your SCOPE should never ever be on the table. "period, end of story" as the saying goes.
The cat is let out of the proverbial bag if you do this and even if the MOA states scope and conditions snap back to contract at the end of the MOA, it's too late, that precedent has been set and it's like telling the cat to get back in the bag 6 months from now. Do cats listen?!
Keep the cat in the bag.
The cat is let out of the proverbial bag if you do this and even if the MOA states scope and conditions snap back to contract at the end of the MOA, it's too late, that precedent has been set and it's like telling the cat to get back in the bag 6 months from now. Do cats listen?!
Keep the cat in the bag.
Re: How to get rid of ACPA?
For the uninformed... the scope “let” you are referring to is what exactly?
Re: How to get rid of ACPA?
By your reasoning, I guess you could therefore expect the ALPA Canada Board to pressure your MEC to hand your work over to WestJet or Encore or Perimeter/Bearskin or any of the other ALPA Canada pilot groups as well. Does this sound reasonable to anyone? Dreamt up misleading bull sh!t like this does not help when your group is contemplating an important decision.Ratherbe wrote: ↑Fri Sep 18, 2020 3:03 pm
We left CALPA because the “tail was wagging the dog,” the union was in financial distress, and that they had pursued a labour relations experiment (industrial merger) that went horribly wrong. I see a real risk of a retreat to CALPA.
We could expect the c-ALPA Board to pressure our MEC to hand over our work to the regionals. In 1993, when the 243 junior AC pilots got laid off, our “brothers” flying dash 8’s we’re getting promoted. Reluctantly, they allowed us to come over and fly as their FO’s. Now we have a strong scope clause that has the potential to shut them down. ACPA fought for that scope language and gave up pay to get it.
A little context -
Interesting to note that IF the “labour relations experiment (industrial merger) that went horribly wrong” had been completed as contemplated by CALPA merger policy, the 243 most junior pilots system wide who were carrying out Air Canada’s business at the time would have been laid off. The majority would have been “regional” pilots. Your unfortunate “mainline” colleagues who were laid off out of system seniority would have kept their jobs and had the ability to bump into positions based on seniority.
This is all water that has long since passed under the bridge and there were plenty of mistakes made during this time period by all parties involved.
I only hope that the new guard learns from them.
Last edited by rxl on Sun Sep 20, 2020 11:59 am, edited 4 times in total.
-
- Rank 3
- Posts: 153
- Joined: Wed Sep 02, 2020 10:24 am
Re: How to get rid of ACPA?
Tons of ALPA fear mongering within the junior group as well.
So many people are just very very uninformed and listen to the bullshit spewed by guys like Ratherbe and take it as gospel.
So many people are just very very uninformed and listen to the bullshit spewed by guys like Ratherbe and take it as gospel.
Re: How to get rid of ACPA?
You may not agree with RippleRock, but consider what he is saying closely. When the company continues to go above and beyond that scope provision after the end of MOA 2 and it is grieved and taken to arbitration (scope is already being violated Right now) you have shot yourself in the foot when making an argument against it. Much easier for an arbitrator to see the companies side or award a lesser award if the pilot group has already agreed to it once. Precedent is huge.
Tread carefully.
Tread carefully.
-
- Rank 8
- Posts: 775
- Joined: Fri Jul 19, 2013 5:19 pm
Re: How to get rid of ACPA?
Might it never go back to the main contract?
Maybe there will just be a string of MOU's lashed together for the next 3 or something years of "industry recovery" and "unprecedented times".
Maybe there will just be a string of MOU's lashed together for the next 3 or something years of "industry recovery" and "unprecedented times".
-
- Rank 3
- Posts: 181
- Joined: Thu Jun 24, 2004 8:26 pm
Re: How to get rid of ACPA?
So we get an increase from 55 to 63 hours as a minimum per month. The fixed rate pilots are paid 75 hours and rightly so, we left them to eat “click ham” for the last six months. I’m almost leaning towards yes just for these guys/gals. No more than the 600 pilots on the street and rescinding the 87 that were to be gone Oct 1/20. For this MOA the Rouge pilots are subject to Mainline wages and working conditions. So one can also argue that a precedent has been set and continue as is and roll it into the mainline once the market returns.
The language in both MOA’s are identical and it does not provide the company any relief with the respect to the CPA flying. But I will say I’m going to be on the webinar on Monday and listen to the exact explanation regarding the code sharing and joint venture.
Bottom line we need to get informed, stay engaged and avoid the “chicken little “ syndrome that certain forum members are pushing.
TS
The language in both MOA’s are identical and it does not provide the company any relief with the respect to the CPA flying. But I will say I’m going to be on the webinar on Monday and listen to the exact explanation regarding the code sharing and joint venture.
Bottom line we need to get informed, stay engaged and avoid the “chicken little “ syndrome that certain forum members are pushing.
TS
-
- Rank 3
- Posts: 153
- Joined: Wed Sep 02, 2020 10:24 am
-
- Rank 4
- Posts: 211
- Joined: Tue Apr 02, 2013 9:24 pm
Re: How to get rid of ACPA?
True, but there will be 194 more pilots on the street that otherwise would've been protected with full pay for 6 months.
Re: How to get rid of ACPA?
“The language in both MOA’s are identical and it does not provide the company any relief with the respect to the CPA flying”
Ok so what is the scope let that RippleRock is talking about?
Ok so what is the scope let that RippleRock is talking about?
Re: How to get rid of ACPA?
The difference is the pilot group agreeing to the scope let this time. When the company continues to violate it at the end of the six months it becomes much harder to argue against in arbitration when you have validated the precedent. It bears further scrutiny.
Re: How to get rid of ACPA?
Which part of ACPA’s scope clause on the CPA carriers is being compromised with this MOA?
-
- Rank 7
- Posts: 501
- Joined: Mon May 17, 2004 4:03 pm
Re: How to get rid of ACPA?
BTD et al,
I’m not sure from a legal sense that it really matters whether a contract, provision, or revision is accepted by the MEC iris voted on by the membership. In a legal sense, it is moot. We could have played Rock Paper Scissors, Bocce, held a vote, acclaimed it, or just had our MEC sign it, it doesn’t matter. It won’t matter one iota to an arbitrator In the future. The company will argue that al”the majority of the pilots accept this” and ACPA will argue that “ this was essentially under duress, with looming financial hardship”, I sense the arbitration will lean towards ACPA.
In summation, I believe that the MOA 1 already has JV revisions. This MOA2 merely codifies it. An future arbitration will not view HOW an agreement was reached, nor the acceptance of revisions. We are in unprecedented times.
Cheers
I’m not sure from a legal sense that it really matters whether a contract, provision, or revision is accepted by the MEC iris voted on by the membership. In a legal sense, it is moot. We could have played Rock Paper Scissors, Bocce, held a vote, acclaimed it, or just had our MEC sign it, it doesn’t matter. It won’t matter one iota to an arbitrator In the future. The company will argue that al”the majority of the pilots accept this” and ACPA will argue that “ this was essentially under duress, with looming financial hardship”, I sense the arbitration will lean towards ACPA.
In summation, I believe that the MOA 1 already has JV revisions. This MOA2 merely codifies it. An future arbitration will not view HOW an agreement was reached, nor the acceptance of revisions. We are in unprecedented times.
Cheers
- Daniel Cooper
- Rank 5
- Posts: 335
- Joined: Thu Dec 20, 2018 6:38 am
- Location: Unknown
Re: How to get rid of ACPA?
Well said tailgunner.
If people are so concerned about some "genie out of the bottle" situation that can't be put back in with the end of the MOAs, well it already got let out 6 months ago anyways.
If people are so concerned about some "genie out of the bottle" situation that can't be put back in with the end of the MOAs, well it already got let out 6 months ago anyways.
Re: How to get rid of ACPA?
Do you all remember in the last reopener when the sky is falling people were screaming that Air Canada would “double Rouge overnight” if we voted yes?
COVID aside, that never happened, of course.
Ignore both extreme opinions and use your head and a little common sense.
COVID aside, that never happened, of course.
Ignore both extreme opinions and use your head and a little common sense.
https://eresonatemedia.com/
https://bambaits.ca/
https://youtube.com/channel/UCWit8N8YCJSvSaiSw5EWWeQ
https://bambaits.ca/
https://youtube.com/channel/UCWit8N8YCJSvSaiSw5EWWeQ
Re: How to get rid of ACPA?
Teacher,
Perhaps you can help me: Which part of ACPA’s scope clause on the CPA carriers is being compromised with this MOA?
Perhaps you can help me: Which part of ACPA’s scope clause on the CPA carriers is being compromised with this MOA?
Re: How to get rid of ACPA?
Scope isn't changed in this MOA. What we are witnessing is a form of hysteria.
Re: How to get rid of ACPA?
Arbitrators can view a member ratified choice differently. It's the reason that we lost all hope of fighting FOS, when we chose to ratify those losses before the court case went through. I'm not saying they would, but I am extremely leery of any let on scope no matter how small. In my eyes, the real risk is if this isn't a short lived pandemic and we end up in CCAA with this voluntary precedent set.Daniel Cooper wrote: ↑Sun Sep 20, 2020 7:47 am Well said tailgunner.
If people are so concerned about some "genie out of the bottle" situation that can't be put back in with the end of the MOAs, well it already got let out 6 months ago anyways.