That’s a Stallin quote isn’t it? Ah back when socialism was at its finest when one was at the top of the portobello!
TPC
Moderators: sky's the limit, sepia, Sulako, North Shore
That’s a Stallin quote isn’t it? Ah back when socialism was at its finest when one was at the top of the portobello!
So these “idiots” had more disposable $ than you and I put together… I really don’t think it appropriate to commensurate on another’s demise.
LOL, rich people. Easy target. What have you accomplished in life, Digits,et all?
It might go out with a bang, but I wouldn't hold my breath!TeePeeCreeper wrote: ↑Sat Jun 24, 2023 12:38 amNope, I can’t say I ever had and I’ve a wicked sense of humour…digits_ wrote: ↑Fri Jun 23, 2023 7:45 amI don't think the event was funny. I never claimed it was. That doesn't mean you can't make jokes about it that some people might find funny. Or that there are certain aspects related to the incident that are somewhat funny.TeePeeCreeper wrote: ↑Thu Jun 22, 2023 11:39 pm
It’s in poor taste digits. Common man, people died ffs! If you think either event was funny in the slightest, I’ve no words to describe your callousness regardless of your wicked sense of humour.
You've never laughed or chuckled at a joke that referenced a dramatic/traumatic event? Ever?
Oh well… maybe this thread will go bottoms up?
TPC
I appreciate the effort there, but as far as I know, the air would have dissolved into the surrounding water quite quickly at that pressure resulting in more of a fizz than a bang.
AvCanada isn’t democracy or subject to Freedom of Speech. It’s a private, for profit website. If someone anonymously posts something that could be considered libel, AvCanada and its owners could be subject to a defamation lawsuit. The law treats message boards similar to a newspaper and if they “publish” something that could be considered libel they could face civil remedies.CanadaAir wrote: ↑Wed Jun 28, 2023 8:52 am As OP, pointing out that many of the posts in this topic include insensitive jokes of the death of 5 people.
viewtopic.php?t=190512
Avcanada mods allow this, and the angry comments in other posts, but delete the topic criticizing Transport Canada for lack of action on repetitive maintenance failures by a regional airline.
A central item of democracy is the ability to openly criticize the government. There’s many topics criticizing the government on covid, or the PM on other policy.
Why illegal on avcanada to criticize TC for not resolving safety concerns that could prevent accidents, while it’s allowed to make fun of 5 people dying in one?
Defamation applies to people, not to the government or Transport Canada.JBI wrote: ↑Wed Jun 28, 2023 2:23 pmAvCanada isn’t democracy or subject to Freedom of Speech. It’s a private, for profit website. If someone anonymously posts something that could be considered libel, AvCanada and its owners could be subject to a defamation lawsuit. The law treats message boards similar to a newspaper and if they “publish” something that could be considered libel they could face civil remedies.CanadaAir wrote: ↑Wed Jun 28, 2023 8:52 am As OP, pointing out that many of the posts in this topic include insensitive jokes of the death of 5 people.
viewtopic.php?t=190512
Avcanada mods allow this, and the angry comments in other posts, but delete the topic criticizing Transport Canada for lack of action on repetitive maintenance failures by a regional airline.
A central item of democracy is the ability to openly criticize the government. There’s many topics criticizing the government on covid, or the PM on other policy.
Why illegal on avcanada to criticize TC for not resolving safety concerns that could prevent accidents, while it’s allowed to make fun of 5 people dying in one?
There was a lawyer/law student message board called Lawbuzz.ca that eventually shut down because they were sued.
You’re always welcome to start your own website and post whatever you want…
Defamation does apply to private companies. I’ve bolded and underlined the key sentence. If there’s any allegations of failures or unsafe practices of a company it is indeed prudent for AvCanada mods to remove such posts/topics.CanadaAir wrote: ↑Wed Jun 28, 2023 5:29 pmDefamation applies to people, not to the government or Transport Canada.JBI wrote: ↑Wed Jun 28, 2023 2:23 pmAvCanada isn’t democracy or subject to Freedom of Speech. It’s a private, for profit website. If someone anonymously posts something that could be considered libel, AvCanada and its owners could be subject to a defamation lawsuit. The law treats message boards similar to a newspaper and if they “publish” something that could be considered libel they could face civil remedies.
There was a lawyer/law student message board called Lawbuzz.ca that eventually shut down because they were sued.
You’re always welcome to start your own website and post whatever you want…
Criticism of government’s protected by charter.
Avcanada mods don’t need to restrict criticism of the government or Transport Canada.
There’s many other comments on the site which are worse than criticism of TC.
You are crushing it! Just like WJ's management.
Dude, I did report it, asked to lock the thread and the response was, report closed by non other than avcanada with literally no change, no edits and the thread continues with the same disgusting jokes.North Shore wrote: ↑Wed Jun 28, 2023 10:23 am Dude, I, and the other mods, have neither the time, nor the inclination, to trawl through every single post and thread on here to see who's panties are getting twisted on a daily basis. If you're that offended, then use the report button (it's the !) in the top right of every post, and it will flag things for our attention.
I'll personally cop to being inconsistent from day to day about why things do or don't get moderated - I can't/won't speak for the others, however.
It has nothing to do with being rich.
Very likely, yes. But it wouldn't have popped up in this topic because there would be no link to Westjet management. But rest assured in other topics or other locations people would have joked about it to process the events, and you'd have your chance to be offended or disgusted by it.
How old are you, and what rock do you live under? Even if it was todlers the internet would be making memes and crude jokes about it a second after it happens.cdnavater wrote: ↑Thu Jun 29, 2023 8:31 amDude, I did report it, asked to lock the thread and the response was, report closed by non other than avcanada with literally no change, no edits and the thread continues with the same disgusting jokes.North Shore wrote: ↑Wed Jun 28, 2023 10:23 am Dude, I, and the other mods, have neither the time, nor the inclination, to trawl through every single post and thread on here to see who's panties are getting twisted on a daily basis. If you're that offended, then use the report button (it's the !) in the top right of every post, and it will flag things for our attention.
I'll personally cop to being inconsistent from day to day about why things do or don't get moderated - I can't/won't speak for the others, however.
It’s apparently ok to make these jokes because they are rich and we hate rich people. Would we make the same jokes if it was a class trip of school kids?
JBI wrote: ↑Wed Jun 28, 2023 8:00 pmDefamation does apply to private companies. I’ve bolded and underlined the key sentence. If there’s any allegations of failures or unsafe practices of a company it is indeed prudent for AvCanada mods to remove such posts/topics.CanadaAir wrote: ↑Wed Jun 28, 2023 5:29 pmDefamation applies to people, not to the government or Transport Canada.JBI wrote: ↑Wed Jun 28, 2023 2:23 pm
AvCanada isn’t democracy or subject to Freedom of Speech. It’s a private, for profit website. If someone anonymously posts something that could be considered libel, AvCanada and its owners could be subject to a defamation lawsuit. The law treats message boards similar to a newspaper and if they “publish” something that could be considered libel they could face civil remedies.
There was a lawyer/law student message board called Lawbuzz.ca that eventually shut down because they were sued.
You’re always welcome to start your own website and post whatever you want…
Criticism of government’s protected by charter.
Avcanada mods don’t need to restrict criticism of the government or Transport Canada.
There’s many other comments on the site which are worse than criticism of TC.
Nonetheless, this is a privately run website. If the owners or mods had a big crush on Omar and only allowed people to say nice things about his sneakers but not anything negative, guess what, that’s totally within their rights. However, I’ve read plenty of criticism of TC on this website.
Right. Are you going to pay Avcanada's lawyer costs when the company you're discussing sues?CanadaAir wrote: ↑Thu Jun 29, 2023 9:55 amJBI wrote: ↑Wed Jun 28, 2023 8:00 pmDefamation does apply to private companies. I’ve bolded and underlined the key sentence. If there’s any allegations of failures or unsafe practices of a company it is indeed prudent for AvCanada mods to remove such posts/topics.CanadaAir wrote: ↑Wed Jun 28, 2023 5:29 pm
Defamation applies to people, not to the government or Transport Canada.
Criticism of government’s protected by charter.
Avcanada mods don’t need to restrict criticism of the government or Transport Canada.
There’s many other comments on the site which are worse than criticism of TC.
Nonetheless, this is a privately run website. If the owners or mods had a big crush on Omar and only allowed people to say nice things about his sneakers but not anything negative, guess what, that’s totally within their rights. However, I’ve read plenty of criticism of TC on this website.
Not for a government or Transport Canada, the charter allows for criticism of the government.
As you point out, defamation of person or corporation could happen if a statement is false.
Stating that an airline has a series of mechanical incidents reducing safety for the pilots & passengers is fact & doesn’t qualify as defamation.
It's not a false statement.
If public safety can be improved by the statement, then it’s not defamation.
Stating that an airline has above average mechanical incidents & Transport Canada should be more concerned & enforcing stricter safety measures isn’t defamation.
Criticizing a corporation is allowed & not defamation if safety’s protected or improved.
This is laid out in the code & backed by charter law.
I guess I’m not a desensitized psycho who thinks as a society this is ok, ok!Tbayer2021 wrote: ↑Thu Jun 29, 2023 8:55 amHow old are you, and what rock do you live under? Even if it was todlers the internet would be making memes and crude jokes about it a second after it happens.cdnavater wrote: ↑Thu Jun 29, 2023 8:31 amDude, I did report it, asked to lock the thread and the response was, report closed by non other than avcanada with literally no change, no edits and the thread continues with the same disgusting jokes.North Shore wrote: ↑Wed Jun 28, 2023 10:23 am Dude, I, and the other mods, have neither the time, nor the inclination, to trawl through every single post and thread on here to see who's panties are getting twisted on a daily basis. If you're that offended, then use the report button (it's the !) in the top right of every post, and it will flag things for our attention.
I'll personally cop to being inconsistent from day to day about why things do or don't get moderated - I can't/won't speak for the others, however.
It’s apparently ok to make these jokes because they are rich and we hate rich people. Would we make the same jokes if it was a class trip of school kids?
What is it with boomers calling everyone else snowflakes, yet they're the ones crying the loudest all the time?
I sincerely hope you don't ever attend a live comedy show. Specially one by a popular comedian.cdnavater wrote: ↑Thu Jun 29, 2023 10:47 amI guess I’m not a desensitized psycho who thinks as a society this is ok, ok!Tbayer2021 wrote: ↑Thu Jun 29, 2023 8:55 amHow old are you, and what rock do you live under? Even if it was todlers the internet would be making memes and crude jokes about it a second after it happens.cdnavater wrote: ↑Thu Jun 29, 2023 8:31 am
Dude, I did report it, asked to lock the thread and the response was, report closed by non other than avcanada with literally no change, no edits and the thread continues with the same disgusting jokes.
It’s apparently ok to make these jokes because they are rich and we hate rich people. Would we make the same jokes if it was a class trip of school kids?
What is it with boomers calling everyone else snowflakes, yet they're the ones crying the loudest all the time?