Big Pistons Forever wrote: Andrew172 I see you are still obsessing about the jammed control scenario. Of all the questions a 10 hr PPL could want to ask on a flight training board why is this the only thing you care about .........
Because it seems that control failure is the only one emergency thing which is not covered in trainings. In my situation, we did all emergency training lessons before my first solo and control failures were not covered. We did all kind of stalls, incipient spin, engine failure and engine fire procedures. I was trained for them all, but control failure is not in my PPL schedule and it will never be. That's why I was asking here.
I'm not obsessed with control emergencies, they are not more important for me than other failures, they are very rare, but the difference is that for an engine fire, I was trained to prevent it and if it happens, I also know how to act to have a chance to surivive. For control failures, I was just trained how to prevent it (and that's not sure, there are ppl who don't pay attention to flight control checks and in this situation, there will be students who don't pay attention to prevent a flight control failure, so in the best case you are trained to prevent it...maybe being prepared to fly with a jammed control is too much ). Don't tell me it is not easier to know that the trim acts opposite when your elevator is jammed or to know that you can yaw your Cessna with doors, or opposite rudder has secondary roll effect and a lot of useful tips I read here. I think you cannot figure them out quickly when you are in trouble. Why don't you learn them all in your PPL training or CPL training? Maybe they are very rare, but as long as they happen, you have to be trained for these situations. Maybe there are still other problems you are not trained for and it's pretty silly that you have to try it in the air when it happens versus being already prepared for it. Also, I know that most accidents happen because of pilot error, usually basic pilot errors like stalling on final, base to final turn spinning or others, but that's not a rational reason for not teaching other plausible rare scenarios after you master the basics and I did it, if that was the problem.
In your opinion, it's better if a CPL student or even CPL holder asks these questions. If I would be, I'm sure I would ask them because I have asked CPL ppl and they were not trained for discussed failures. In my opinion, it is better to know them from my first solo, because you don't know when it happens, from my first solo to CPL it's a very long time, a lot of things can happen, why not being prepared for them? It's stupid. |
|