Cat Driver wrote:The examiner did not look outside the airplane at any time during the circuit join , circuit and approach?
Dont' be a dumbass CAT; yes he did, and doing those huge 747 circuits that inexperienced pilots always do, it is totally conceivable, especially with a low wing piper, that the candidate was looking at one field the examiner at another...or the FTE couldn't see it at all from the right side of the airplane.
Or, the candidate was looking at the right field all along, but when descending on base, turning final, was low enough to mistake the farmer's field for Ft. Langley. Even on final, the FTE still may have been looking at the right field, just thinking the candidate was a little low. A good instructor lets his/her students make mistakes, just doesn't let them progress to a dangerous point. Being low on approach, especially a short field, would not be cause for alarm.
I knew that DFTE....a stand up guy and an experienced(I mean like a life of experience...not just 2 or 3 years) pilot and examiner. Did he make a mistake? Obviously. He should have had his head up on short final. Was the student at fault? Absolutely. This was a 180 hr licensed private pilot with a multi engine instrument rating, who, I might add, had some of the Ace McCool attitude going on. Time for him to eat some humble pie apparently. Just glad him learning a lesson didn't kill anyone.
Anyways, this chat is hijacking this thread....sorry to others....CAT just sometimes opines on things that he doesn't know much about.
in the spirit of the original thread....I would think that the PPR won't be a problem for most GA pilots.....hopefully the new owner just wants to know who's coming...like the many airstrip owners on the Gulf Islands. For soft field training, there's Langley (CYNJ) which is safer anyways, and a public airport that will probably never(well, who can say never?) go private.