CHRT Remedy Ruling?

[Widow]

No, but please note that Mr. Hall will no longer be contributing to these discussions.

[flightlevel]

Just beginning to read these pages on this topic, I kind of expect a little more tact and respect in terms of responses to questions from any member of any bar association in this country. Just Saying.

[Lost in Saigon]

No, but please note that Mr. Hall will no longer be contributing to these discussions.

Why?

[yycflyguy]

No, but please note that Mr. Hall will no longer be contributing to these discussions.

Why?

Just throwing this out there. Maybe the owner of the board didn't appreciate threats of litigation so he removed the problem.

[Widow]

viewtopic.php?f=31&t=66805

Suggest discussion remains ON TOPIC before the whole subject gets banned.

[ivanhoe]

EDITED

[Mechanic787]

It sure has been quiet here lately. Can anyone provide an update regarding what is happening with the Tribunal or with the announced reinstatements?

[yycflyguy]

Probably wont be too much to talk about about the Remedy is release sometime in November. The debate does get quiet when half the story is removed.

[Lost in Saigon]

The Chairman Sinclair "Remedy" decision is long overdue and should be out any day now. The Judicial Review is scheduled for November.

[flyinhigh]

Widow, i can't be bothered to read all this.

Did the main guy Hall actually come on here and threaten litigation against avcanada for having this discussion?

If so, so much for freedom of speech.

[yycflyguy]

The Chairman Sinclair "Remedy" decision is long overdue and should be out any day now. The Judicial Review is scheduled for November.

Right you are...

[Mechanic787]

Did the main guy Hall actually come on here and threaten litigation against avcanada for having this discussion

No. There was one post made by an individual using his real name that included a statement alleged as fact that Mr. Hall had taken a particular action against certain individuals. Hall denied the assertion and demanded that the individual immediately remove the post, "or face the consequences." He made no threats against this Forum or against any of the moderators of this Forum.

[mduffy]

Ahhhh... so he only threatened one of our users. Nice.

[Mechanic787]

Ahhhh... so he only threatened one of our users. Nice.

It raises an interesting issue, perhaps worthy of a separate thread. The starting point is that he was one of the few posting here who was willing to let his own name stand behind his posts. In my view, that took more than courage, given his obvious role in the controversy, it took a willingness to stand up to critical attacks by those who choose to remain anonymous.

But there comes a point, especially where the attacks are untrue, unfounded or just plain vicious, that one ought to be able to properly react. All of these Forums have guidelines re proper usage, including prohibitions against defamatory posts, but from my experience, there is a wide distance between the guidelines and the actual behavior. To be fair to the moderators, they do not have an easy job, and quite often they may not be alerted to offending posts until after quite a bit of damage is already done.

I can see why the moderators or the owner of this site would be nervous, when the legal fur starts to fly. But there is a real downside to punting an individual who is only demanding that he be treated on the Forum in the manner that the Forum rules dictate. Especially when that person is one who provides a wealth of factual information, albeit, somewhat biased.

[bcflyer]

The comments in question were made by someone using their own name and were based on facts. There was nothing vicious or untrue about them. We have several ACPA newsletters to that effect... Haven't heard what the final outcome was.

[Raymond Hall]

There was nothing vicious or untrue about them. We have several ACPA newsletters to that effect... Haven't heard what the final outcome was.

The issue is closed. The post was removed. However, I can assure you that the content of the post did not come from any
ACPA Newsletter. It was personal, and it has been dealt with.

[yycflyguy]

um, welcome back?

... guess I am going to have to change my signature again

[beast]

It was my understanding that RH had been banned from this forum?? mods?

[Johnny Mapleleaf]

It was my understanding that RH had been banned from this forum??

Let's cover our eyes and plug our ears. We are once again at risk of having our minds corrupted with factual information about what is really going on, not to mention the risk of having to respond to considered opinions and the truth.

[Widow]

Stay on topic "CHRT Remedy Ruling" or the thread will be locked and/or YOU will be given a time out.

[Johnny Mapleleaf]

Stay on topic "CHRT Remedy Ruling" or the thread will be locked and/or YOU will be given a time out.

My apologies for the satire. I was simply, but perhaps not clearly, suggesting that whoever made the decision to rescind the banishment made a good decision. His participation here adds significant value to the site's contribution to the context of critical issues in our environment.

[Understated]

Decision coming soon?

[Raymond Hall]

All the parties to the Vilven-Kelly Tribunal hearing were informed this morning that the Tribunal's decision will be released Monday, November 8th, at 9:30 AM Eastern time.

[JayDee]

ACPA Theme Song


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e3zSV19AksQ


Oh Monday morning, Monday morning couldn't guarantee
That Monday evening you would still be here with me.

Monday Monday, can't trust that day,
Monday Monday, sometimes it just turns out that way
Oh Monday morning, you gave me no warning of what was to be
Oh Monday Monday, how could you leave and not take me.


Back up song >> http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9CqVYPVCR9M



FlyPast60 Theme Song


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tJNk6I9D ... re=related


"Oh... it doesn’t matter what you wear
Just as long as you are there so come on
Every guy grab a girl everywhere around the world
They’ll be dancing
They’re dancin’ in the street ( dancing in the street)"

[Max111]

,

That was just to funny ! A bit of sunshine ! No matter what side of the issue you are on.....You had to enjoy that. There is so much talent and imagination within the whole pilots group....I /we thank you for this JayDee !!