Ohhhhh you're absolutely right. I mean who wouldn't turn down jazz to prove that they are a REAL pilot. If bush flying is the real flying then why do a good junk of pilots aim for the airlines?To me the most important point is that if you are hired directly out of college, then you not only miss out on all the "learning events" that result from years in the bush, but you also miss the chance to prove to yourself that you ACTUALLY want to be a pilot.
Right dude....let's compare a pilot who sat in his C172 for 1500 hours not even flying a plane, then hoping on a turbine flying that for a bit and going to jazz, compared to someone who's been flying a dash 8 for a couple thousand hours right from the start? new flash, not all pilots are true bush pilots. Half of them probably don't leave the city.Take some of the pilots to whom you referred, pair them up with a recent college grad, and put them in some of the challenging situations that come up thankfully rarely
And I guarantee you, you're gonna write back about how you didn't instruct and blah blah blah. Well excatly, if you don't like hearing a lame story of how airline pilots are just instructors with lots of hours, then please don't go judging the college people. Maybe if you took the time to actually look into it you, may see that not all college kids are stuck up pricks that started at jazz with only 250 hours that enjoy their arts and craft time.
It's about a pointless as a 20,000 hour captain on a 747 saying that a 5000 hour rookie pilot shouldn't be flying a 747 because he needs to get real industry experience first (as in some parts of the world).
No offense to any instructors out there, I'm just trying to prove a point. I instruct myself....so please don't get hung up on it.